Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Home / Environment / Romney’s green-jobs criticism carries risks

Romney’s green-jobs criticism carries risks

By Nicholas Riccardi
Associated Press

Republican presidential candidate Mitt Romney campaigns at Acme Industries in Elk Grove Village, Ill., on Tuesday. A Romney campaign spokesman said last week that Congress should let a tax break for wind energy producers expire at the end of the year. (AP Photo/Charles Dharapak)

DENVER — Mitt Romney’s presidential campaign has been savaging what it calls President Barack Obama’s “unhealthy” obsession with “green jobs.”

The Republican challenger criticizes the government program that propped up solar manufacturer Solyndra, and he mocks Obama’s vision of a boom in employment, citing a European study to argue that new solar or wind energy positions would destroy jobs elsewhere.

But when a campaign spokesman said last week that Congress should let a tax break for wind energy producers expire at the end of the year, some Republicans were concerned the candidate had gone too far.

Republican Rep. Tom Latham, R-Iowa, noting that nearly 7,000 Iowans work in the wind industry, assailed the Romney campaign for “a lack of full understanding of how important the wind energy tax credit is for Iowa and our nation.”

Iowa’s senior senator, Chuck Grassley, told reporters he didn’t believe Romney really opposed the extension, and he joined five other GOP lawmakers in voting for it in the Senate Finance Committee.

The Obama campaign quickly organized conference calls for reporters and circulated fact sheets showing the deep support the credit has in such swing-voting states as Iowa, Colorado and Nevada.

Obama will appear in Denver and western Colorado Wednesday to promote his economic plan, and the wind tax credit might come up.

The backlash on the wind tax statement shows the risks Romney takes in targeting a fast-growing and popular industry Obama has embraced. However, Romney’s aides argue the campaign is just making a principled economic argument against excessive government interference in the marketplace.

It’s an argument the conservative movement, which Romney has struggled to win over, has praised.

Indeed, Patrick Hedger, a researcher at FreedomWorks, a small-government group that is a prominent backer of the tea party movement, called Romney’s position “a happy surprise.” Hedger added that Republicans who feared a political cost from Romney’s position were stuck in an outdated way of thinking.

“We’ve got to get out of this cycle,” Hedger said, “of buying votes with money we don’t have.”

But critics contend Romney, who counts members of the fossil fuels industry as major financial supporters and relies on the leader of an oil company as his energy adviser, has backed himself into a corner.

“I think it’s really a knee-jerk reaction to what this president has done,” said Jeff Gohringer, a spokesman for the League of Conservation Voters. “He (Romney) is actually going to states and advocating cutting thousands of their jobs.”

Surveys show the industry’s popularity. A Gallup poll in March found Americans nearly twice as likely to favor wind and solar energy as coal or oil.

The American Wind Energy Association released a poll last month showing that more than half of Iowa’s voters say they would not back a presidential candidate who did not support expanding wind power. The January poll by Colorado College found that a majority of voters in six Western states — including nearly two-thirds of Coloradans — believe that expanding renewable energy will create more jobs.

In Colorado, GOP Rep. Doug Lamborn said he was pleased the Romney campaign took a stand against the tax credit.

“It shows he’s standing on principle and not pandering to win votes,” Lamborn said. But Lamborn is the only one of the state’s seven congressional representatives to oppose the extension.

Obama made green jobs a focus of his 2008 campaign, and he included in federal stimulus efforts tens of billions of dollars in incentives to promote energy efficiency and the renewable industry. After Solyndra’s bankruptcy last year, Republicans lined up to criticize the administration program that guaranteed the firm’s loans, and Romney has broadened the attack to the administration’s support for the entire industry, even in states where it is popular.

During a May stop in Colorado, Romney mocked Obama for spending billions to create “green jobs.” He asked the crowd: “Have you seen those jobs anywhere?”

President Barack Obama speaks after touring Sempra's Copper Mountain Solar 1 facility in Boulder City, Nev., on March 21. Romney has criticized Obama for spending billions to create green jobs. (AP File Photo/Julie Jacobson)

The Romney campaign argues that what it calls “much-ballyhooed” wind and solar jobs may actually lessen the total number of jobs available because they replace positions in dirtier, but more labor-intensive industries. It cites a controversial Spanish study that found that every renewable energy job in that country destroyed 2.2 others.

“In place of real energy, Obama has focused on an imaginary world where government-subsidized windmills and solar panels could power the economy,” Romney wrote in a March op-ed piece published in The Columbus Dispatch in Ohio. “This vision has failed.”

The Obama campaign has been eager to respond, especially after an Iowa Romney campaign spokesman, Shawn McCoy, said last week that the candidate favored doing away with the wind tax credit.

“Mitt Romney would slash investments in clean energy, which would cede leadership of these critical sectors of our economy to competitors like China and India — and the jobs that go with them,” according to a statement from the Obama campaign that added the Republican has opposed ending tax breaks for the oil industry.

The American Wind Energy Association estimates that 37,000 jobs would be lost if the tax credit isn’t extended this year. The credit was created in a 1992 energy bill signed by President George H.W. Bush and was renewed in a 2005 measure that passed a Republican Congress and was signed by President George W. Bush.

The Obama administration gave Romney an opening by overselling the promise of renewable energy jobs, said Jonathan Rothwell, a senior associate at the Brookings Institution who helped write a report on the growth of green jobs. The jobs will come, Rothwell said, but it will probably take a couple of decades.

“The Obama administration,” he said, “did exaggerate the short-term benefits of the green economy by implying it would drive us out of the recession.”

Rothwell noted that renewable energy jobs are well-dispersed across the country and, while small in number, are growing rapidly.

“That explains why there is broad and, in some cases, bipartisan support,” he said.

The issue came up Tuesday during an annual green energy conference hosted by Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid in Las Vegas. Reid said he is confident the credit extension would pass by the end of the year.

Obama’s interior secretary, former Colorado Sen. Ken Salazar, noted the Senate Finance Committee recently agreed on the proposal to extend the wind energy tax credit.

“That shows it ought not to be a Republican or Democratic issue,” Salazar said. “It ought to be an American issue.”

Associated Press writer Ken Ritter also contributed to this report from Las Vegas.

Green energy, politics lead agenda at Vegas summit

LAS VEGAS (AP) — The politics of renewable energy headed the agenda in battleground Nevada, where Democratic Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid and Interior Secretary Ken Salazar opened a fifth annual green energy conference touting the start of a 12-square-mile wind energy farm in rural White Pine County.

San Francisco-based Pattern Energy’s Spring Valley project is the first wind major wind farm in Nevada and is designed to produce to up to 150 megawatts of electricity, or enough to power 45,000 homes. Salazar called it an example of an Obama administration strategy toward freeing the use of federal lands for energy production.

In Washington, the administration announced Tuesday that seven solar and wind energy projects in Arizona, California, Nevada and Wyoming would be fast-tracked. Officials said they together could produce nearly 5,000 megawatts, or enough to power 1.5 million homes.

“We’ve come too far to allow the clock of progress to be turned back,” Salazar said at the conference focusing on wind, solar and geothermal energy.

President Barack Obama and Republican candidate Mitt Romney have differing approaches to domestic energy production.

Obama touts renewable energy, while Romney wants to reduce obstacles to coal, natural gas and nuclear energy development. Romney also supports opening the Atlantic and Pacific outer continental shelves to drilling, as well as Western lands, the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge and offshore Alaska. He says green power has yet to become viable and the causes of climate change are unknown.

A Romney aide said Tuesday that Congress should let a tax break for wind energy producers expire at the end of the year. But Salazar said the Senate Finance Committee agreed last week on a bipartisan proposal to extend the production tax credit for wind energy.

“That shows it ought not to be a Republican or Democratic issue, it ought to be an American issue,” Salazar told nearly 700 people during his morning speech at the Bellagio resort. “Our national security, our economic security, our environmental security, those are American issues and everyone should stand behind them.”

Reid told reporters he’d like the measure to pass before the November election, but he was confident it would pass by the end of the year.

Salazar told the conference that a planned 3,000-megawatt wind power complex in Wyoming would provide electricity to homes as far away as Nevada and California. He also touted administration efforts to spur the first Atlantic Ocean wind energy projects. The U.S. currently has no operating offshore wind farms, but Salazar said the Cape Wind project off Massachusetts has received permits to become the first.

The conference was expected to feature an afternoon address by Bill Clinton, a “fireside chat” involving the former president and his former White House chief-of-staff, John Podesta, and a closing speech by Reid.

Republicans have blamed Obama for granting more than $500 million in federal stimulus loan guarantees to the Solyndra Inc. solar power project in California. The venture declared bankruptcy in September. Other companies with smaller loan guarantees have also folded.

The Obama administration said losses were expected when Congress set aside $10 billion for high-risk program loan guarantees to projects that would have trouble obtaining private financing. It points to a former Treasury Department official’s report saying more rigorous financial oversight and stricter performance standards could reduce the risk of future defaults.

— KEN RITTER, Associated Press

Copyright 2021 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *